Hi Lana, I see it, Andy she's not on page 1 "everything" click on Places and it's on bottom of page 2 for me.
Since I specialize in Dentistry I had to take a peek to see if I could help you, but I don't know how to fix that one and have never seen it happen before. My guess is it's a temporary glitch and will clear up soon. Try hitting some inbound links. A couple a day to leave a bread crumb for Google to follow to your site to try to get her to pick up the correct info.
Wanted to just mention though, Google has some oddball results for your area when you search "dentist 10174".
The C listing is a Dental DIRECTORY with a bunch of NY Dentists listed. 1st time I've seen a directory make it into the merged local listings.
The one that comes up as H for me, is for "Tooth Fairy" which is a BOOK or movie or something and G built a Place page and gave it category Dentist. It has 462 reviews! More than any Dentist in the area. :-)